Looking for:
Zip.exe download windows |
EXE vs Zip for software downloads.File Overview
This is a kind of grievance, so take it as you will. So, you know how some Windows software companies provide a Zip file with their installer EXE inside it, and some just put up the EXE and dispense with that extra step? It seems like half the companies do one and half do the other. Is there some advantage to encapsulating EXEs in Zip files? The Zip files are always the same size and in some cases larger.
To me its irritating and apparently no one else either cares or has shouted enough about it to get them to change. Or maybe I'm just a cranky old man and everything irritates me now.
I think EXE files are often blocked, because they're often used by malware. Also, EXE files can be executed "immediately" after downloading from a website, making it easier for people to install the software - which is great, but is an issue if it's malware.
It creates an extra step that might make people think about what they're doing and maybe stops them from just installing anything. Hide inside a level so deep that malware scanners won't bother to scan in. EXE files often contain a lot of wasted space allocated, but unfilled arrays or fixed buffers, for example. Compressing them allows the file size to be reduced. The consensus is that zips are better and I'm being out-voted.
They must have a good reason. I'm in their side on this and they're on mine! If you distribute a. This confuses some wanna-be-sys-admins and manager types, and will then lead to them abandoning otherwise perfectly good software. With a. Also realize that any. So, any legit software maker trying to distribute a file, has to deal with one of these two issues. My take - get over it - Windows pseudo-security nonsense prompts are an attempt to protect end-users, and inadvertently makes your job have a few extra steps.
File size was reduced by 22KB. It's about the same with solarwinds apps. Most ALL installers nowadays have very good compression, and for a good reason. Thing is, when you unzip, Windows yells at you about signed EXEs anyway, so you still get that "hey, is this legit?
It just doesn't seem to matter that it's zipped or not, you still get dumb security warnings that should deter wanna-be's. Sure, I can get over it, but I can tell you right now, I've skipped over zipped installers because I thot they were stupid for doing that, making me jump thru hoops. I've been downloading zipped EXE's and EXE installers for 20 years and just thot "Get over it, that's just how different companies are.
You're not gonna change anything by yelling about it. But it's for godsakes. I had to say something. And who uses IE anymore? Kinda sad tho! At least Spiceworks is doing it right using EXEs instead of zip. If I made a pros and cons list, the cons for using Zip for that would be much longer than pros. But you're right, why bother when I keep replying to people on here like I did with you and I keep getting push back from completely different people?
Not one person, not even from Spiceworks, has chimed in to agree. That's cool. If Spiceworks is doing it so wrong and not another person out of a million on here thinks it should be EXE's, why is Spiceworks still doing it that way? Why aren't they getting the wanna-be's emailing or posting on here saying they can't use Spiceworks because it looks like malware? My point is that if large companies who are both smart Spiceworks and Solarwinds use different methods and no one seems to have a problem with either both have millions of users , then why not distribute in a way that's easy for most users?
I sure wish Spiceworks would tell us why they chose exe's instead of the "much better" zip format, because according to their own users, Spiceworks is doing it wrong.
Microsoft uses mostly EXE installers too. For the Mac agent, we're going to use a zip. This is because the download changes the permissions of the installer script, and so the install fails for users.
Unfortunately there's enough users out there that don't know they need to change permissions on this so they can run it, and it becomes a support issue. Thus, for that, we're resorting to a. That makes sense on the Mac side Jackie. I think we're more concerned about the Windows side. I'd love to hear something that makes sense to me today.
I can't explain why we started doing it - it's always been that way. But for me, it seems more typical of a windows download for an installer to be an executable versus a zip you just have to unpack. One less step. Thanks Schmoo! MS zips their ISOs? I didn't know that! This topic has been locked by an administrator and is no longer open for commenting.
To continue this discussion, please ask a new question. Happy Holidays to everyone here, regardless of what or how y Your daily dose of tech news, in brief. Welcome to the Snap! You need to hear this. There are a few older posts I see, but on average, how much e-mail does your e-mail protection block in a day.
Just want to get an i Hi team,Since family meetings are coming for Christmas, and even new year and all. I was wondering something, because I know this question will come up to me and I will literally stutter explaining it.
When some new people comes to your life, that are non If you've been active in the Community for a while, you probably come across our Year in Review, a feature that rounds up annual Spiceworks activity and surfaces top content from the last 12 months. In this post, we're sharing what's happened in the Commu Online Events.
Login Join. Back from the grave! Feliks Kasparek. Contest ends Contests Complete the steps in order to get the chance to win. Contest Details View all contests. Oliver Kinne This person is a verified professional. Verify your account to enable IT peers to see that you are a professional. Spice 1 flag Report. A ZIP also allows "readme," license, and other files to be included. FWIW, we block both types as attachments. Spice 2 flag Report. Furthermore you may want to check the security hash that is usually provided in case the download mirrors get compromised and different contents are in the file.
Compressed zip are commonly used without much exaggerated compression and it can give users instructions or read. OP Feliks Kasparek. Note the complexity of this issue Same thing with vendors zipping. Microsoft, cough cough Spice 1 flag Report.
Jackie Spiceworks This person is a verified professional. Microsoft, cough cough Thanks Schmoo! Jackie Spiceworks wrote: I can't explain why we started doing it - it's always been that way. Now that makes sense! One less step! Exactly what I was thinking.
Now I feel better and can get back to work. Read these next
No comments:
Post a Comment